What does this comparison help the reader understand?

Understand Words and Language Structures · TELPAS Grades 8–9 reading. The correct answer, and the reasoning behind it.

Reporting category 1: work out what words and phrases mean from context, and understand how sentences and word forms work.

Read the passage. Then answer the questions.

The Long Road South

Every fall, millions of monarch butterflies leave Canada and the northern United States and fly south toward the mountains of central Mexico. For many of them, the route runs straight through Texas. Because the monarchs from the eastern half of North America are all heading for the same small area of Mexico, their paths draw closer together as they travel, like sand pouring through a funnel. Texas sits near the narrow end of that funnel. That is why people in places such as Austin and San Antonio sometimes see dozens of monarchs resting in a single tree in October.

The journey is remarkable because no butterfly making it has ever made it before. A monarch born in early summer usually lives only a few weeks. It mates, lays eggs, and dies, and its offspring continue the cycle. The monarchs that hatch at the end of summer are different. Their bodies put off breeding and store energy instead, and they can live for several months. That is long enough to fly thousands of miles, spend the winter in the cool mountain forests of Mexico, and begin the trip north in the spring.

On the way back, Texas matters again. Many of the returning monarchs lay their eggs in Texas in early spring. They lay them only on milkweed, because milkweed is the only kind of plant monarch caterpillars can eat. If a female cannot find milkweed, she cannot lay her eggs where her caterpillars will survive.

Scientists who measure the area the butterflies cover in their winter forests have reported that the eastern monarch population has dropped sharply since the 1990s. The loss of milkweed is considered one of the main causes, along with the loss of other habitat and changes in weather. As a result, many Texas schools, parks, and families now plant native milkweed and other flowering plants. A garden only a few feet wide can give a traveling monarch a place to feed, and a female a place to lay her eggs.

The question

Choose the best answer.

In paragraph 1, the author compares the butterflies' paths to sand pouring through a funnel. What does this comparison help the reader understand?

  • The monarchs move slowly, the way sand falls.
  • The monarchs fly close to the ground in Texas.
  • The paths get closer as they head south.Correct answer
  • Only a small number of monarchs reach Texas.

Why “The paths get closer as they head south.” is correct

This tests understanding of a comparison (an analogy). A funnel is wide at the top and narrow at the bottom, so sand pouring through it is squeezed together. The sentence just before the comparison says the paths "draw closer together," which is the clue.

Why the other answers are wrong

  • The monarchs move slowly, the way sand falls. — The comparison is about the shape of the paths, not the speed of the butterflies.
  • The monarchs fly close to the ground in Texas. — The passage says nothing about how high the monarchs fly.
  • Only a small number of monarchs reach Texas. — The passage says the opposite: many monarchs pass through Texas.

Practice more of this

More reading practice for Grades 8–9, or see the TELPAS practice test for 8th and 9th grade.

This is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Texas Education Agency or the official TELPAS program. All questions here are original practice material written to match the published test design.